The New England Patriots are in a mess after Sunday’s 35-10 loss to the Detroit Lions. Star quarterback Drake Maye is believed to have a fractured right ankle and will miss time “indefinitely, if not for the season,” per Sports Illustrated. The team is now looking at options outside the roster, with some voices suggesting a reunion with Jimmy Garoppolo. That idea is a bad one. The front office should not sign the 35-year-old just to fill a hole.
He has not even been a full-time starter since 2023. His last full season with the Raiders saw him throw seven touchdowns against nine interceptions in just seven games. There is no recent tape to show he can still make plays. Signing a player with no current form is a gamble New England cannot afford right now.
The Myth of Experience
Proponents argue Garoppolo knows the system because he spent time with Josh McDaniels. It is true he played under the offensive coordinator in New England and Las Vegas. But knowing the playbook does not mean a player can execute it at a high level in 2026. The Patriots already have two quarterbacks who know the system: Tommy DeVito and rookie Behren Morton.
Coach Mike Vrabel addressed the need for an outside addition on Monday morning. He said, “I don’t see that being the case right now,” according to Sports Illustrated. Vrabel added that the team will have conversations but did not commit to bringing in anyone new. The head coach seems to trust his current room more than a washed-up veteran.
Why The Current Plan Works Better
Tommy DeVito took over for Maye on Sunday and the offense struggled. He completed 50% of his passes and threw an interception while taking four sacks. His passer rating was a poor 54.3. Yet, Vrabel did not panic. When asked about DeVito’s performance, the coach said, “I don’t think it was good enough, I think there were things that he missed.” That is honest feedback, not a reason to dump the backup.
In two weeks, the team faces a game against the Los Angeles Chargers. Vrabel alluded to DeVito being the starter for that matchup. Bringing in Garoppolo would disrupt the chemistry DeVito and Morton are building. It would also send a message that the team has no faith in its own players. The Patriots need stability, not a short-term fix that might fail.
Maye will be traveling back to Foxborough shortly after his testing in Germany, per reports. Vrabel told WEEI’s The Greg Hill Show, “Out of caution, Drake stayed back.” The focus must remain on the young players already on the roster. The trade deadline passed on Nov. 10, leaving free agency as the only path. Even then, the best move is to let DeVito and Morton fight for the job.
Vrabel shared his view on the future timeline with reporters. He stated, “I wouldn’t imagine [Maye] being available when we come out of the bye.” This confirms the quarterback room is in flux for the rest of the year. The Patriots must stick with what they have.
