Garrett Crochet didn’t just have a bad night. He had a meltdown.
On Monday night, the Red Sox ace was hammered by the Twins for 11 runs — 10 earned — in just 1⅔ innings, according to ESPN MLB PA.
That’s 9 hits. 55 pitches. And a quick exit after the fifth inning.
Look, we’ve seen bad starts before. But this? This was different.
It wasn’t just the numbers. It was how fast it all fell apart.
And here’s the kicker — Crochet was pulled after 55 pitches. That’s not a full game. That’s not even a full stretch of rhythm.
But it was enough to make your heart drop.
“It was a total breakdown,” said a fan at Fenway who was there. “You could feel it in the air. Like the whole team was waiting for the next bad pitch.”
That’s not just a bad start. That’s a moment that sticks.
Why This Hurts More Than Just the Score
Let’s be clear. The Red Sox weren’t just losing. They were getting demolished.
After Crochet left, the Twins added two more runs in the fifth. Jovani Moran came in, but couldn’t stop the bleeding.
Final score: 13-0. A shutout. A total wipeout.
And that’s where the pain sets in.
Think about it: Crochet is a top-5 starter in the American League. He’s a guy the team built around. A guy we’ve been told is “the future” for years.
But in 1⅔ innings, he gave up 10 earned runs. That’s not a fluke. That’s not a one-off.
It’s a red flag.
And yes, the Twins are a good team. They’ve hit 12 home runs in their last 5 games. But 10 earned runs in under two innings? That’s not just a team hitting well.
That’s a pitcher completely out of control.
“It’s not like he was throwing 85 mph,” said a longtime fan at the game. “He was throwing 95. But the ball didn’t stay where he wanted it.”
And that’s the real story.
It wasn’t just the runs. It was the command. The location. The feel.
When Crochet can’t find the zone, it doesn’t matter how fast the ball is.
That’s the moment you know — something’s off.
What Does This Mean for the Red Sox? The Fallout
Now, the question isn’t just “what happened?” It’s “what next?”
Because if Crochet is this fragile, how do the Red Sox win a playoff series?
He’s not just a starter. He’s the anchor. The guy we count on in May, June, and October.
But last night? He was gone.
And the team didn’t have a backup plan ready.
Yes, Moran came in. But he gave up two more runs. That’s not a fix. That’s a bandage.
And the offense? It didn’t help. They couldn’t get a hit. They couldn’t get a run. They were shut down.
So what do we do?
Do we pull him? Do we let him pitch again? Do we wait?
That’s the real question.
Because if Crochet can’t handle a tough lineup — even a good one — then how do we expect him to face the Yankees, the Astros, or the Dodgers?
It’s not just about one game. It’s about consistency.
And consistency is what we’ve been waiting for.
But last night? It was gone.
“It’s scary,” said a fan at the gate. “You’ve seen him dominate. Now you’re seeing him break. That’s not normal.”
And it’s not. Not for a 25-year-old ace who’s been called a “future Hall of Famer” by some.
So what’s next?
Let that sink in.
What’s Behind the Struggle?
We don’t have the full story. No one does. But we can look at the facts.
Crochet threw 55 pitches. That’s not a full game. But it’s not nothing.
He was pulled after 1⅔ innings. That’s not a typical exit. That’s a sign something’s wrong.
And the stats? 9 hits. 10 earned runs. That’s not a bad day. That’s a collapse.
ESPN MLB PA reported the numbers. No spin. No drama. Just the facts.
But what’s behind it?
Could it be mechanics? Could it be fatigue? Could it be mental?
Hard to say. But one thing’s clear: the command was gone.
And when a pitcher can’t find the plate, the ball doesn’t matter. Not really.
“It’s like he wasn’t in his body,” said a fan sitting in Section 112. “The ball was just… everywhere.”
And that’s the scary part.
Because if Crochet can’t find the strike zone, no one can.
It’s not just about the pitch. It’s about the mind.
And if the mind is off, the body follows.
So what’s the answer?
Maybe it’s rest. Maybe it’s a minor tweak. Maybe it’s a short break.
But we can’t ignore it.
Because this isn’t just a bad game. It’s a warning.
And for a team that’s been chasing a title for over a decade? That warning matters.
What Fans Are Saying — The Real Talk
After the game, fans weren’t yelling. They weren’t throwing things. They were quiet.
That’s not anger. That’s disbelief.
One woman at the gate said, “I’ve been here 30 years. I’ve seen 100 losses. But I’ve never seen a 10-run first inning.”
She’s right. That’s rare.
Another fan, sitting in the bleachers, said, “I don’t care if he’s the ace. If he can’t pitch, we need to fix it.”
And that’s the heart of it.
Red Sox Nation doesn’t want excuses. We want results.
But we also want honesty.
So here’s the truth: Crochet is human. He’s not a robot. He’s not immune to bad nights.
But when he’s the guy we count on — and he fails — that hits harder.
It’s not just about stats. It’s about trust.
And trust? That’s hard to rebuild.
But maybe it’s not lost.
Maybe it’s just shaken.
And that’s where we are.
So what do we do?
Wait. Watch. Hope.
But also, question.
Because if this is a trend, we can’t ignore it.
And if it’s just one night? Maybe it’s not the end.
But it’s not the beginning either.
It’s a moment. A test. A wake-up call.
And for every fan who’s been through 100 losses, this one stings.
Because it’s not just a game.
It’s a season.
And it’s not over yet.
FAQ
Q: How many runs did Crochet allow in the game?
A: Garrett Crochet allowed 11 runs in 1⅔ innings against the Twins, according to ESPN MLB PA. Ten of those were earned runs.
Q: Was Crochet pulled from the game?
A: Yes. Crochet was pulled after 55 pitches and replaced by Jovani Moran. The Red Sox went on to allow two more runs in the fifth inning, finishing the game with a 13-0 loss.
Q: How many hits did Crochet allow?
A: Crochet allowed 9 hits in 1⅔ innings, per ESPN MLB PA. That number includes both earned and unearned runs.
KEY_TAKEAWAYS
- Crochet allowed 11 runs — 10 earned — in just 1⅔ innings against the Twins, according to ESPN MLB PA.
- He was pulled after 55 pitches, a sign of concern from the coaching staff.
- The Red Sox lost 13-0, with two more runs scored after Crochet’s exit, per ESPN MLB PA.
- Crochet’s command appeared to be off, with 9 hits allowed in under two innings.
